Loading...
Understanding and responding to objections from Outreach Judaism, Jews for Judaism, and modern counter-missionary movements with scholarly rigor and pastoral sensitivity.
Former Orthodox rabbi, prolific podcaster and author. Focuses on linguistic arguments claiming Christian Bible mistranslates Hebrew. His radio show "Let's Get Biblical" reaches a wide audience.
Director of Jews for Judaism Canada. Focuses on "cult recovery" and helping Jews who have become Christians return to Judaism.
Author of "26 Reasons Why Jews Don't Believe in Jesus." Attorney by training, presents systematic arguments against Christian claims about Jesus.
Author of "The Jew and the Christian Missionary." Pioneer of modern counter-missionary apologetics. Many current arguments originate from his work.
Counter-Missionary Argument (Tovia Singer / Outreach Judaism)
"Jesus did not fulfill messianic prophecies (the world is not at peace, the temple was destroyed)"
Response
The "unfulfilled prophecies" argument fails to recognize the two-coming framework. Many prophecies await fulfillment at Christ's return. The first coming and second coming distinction is consistent with Old Testament prophecy that describes Messiah's suffering (Isaiah 53) and Messiah's reigning (Isaiah 11) as if simultaneous. The suffering must precede the glory.
Counter-Missionary Argument (Multiple counter-missionaries)
"Christian translations are mistranslations of Hebrew"
Response
Christian translations have been thoroughly defended through textual scholarship. The Septuagint pre-Christian Jewish translation supports many key Christian readings (parthenos for almah, "pierced" in Psalm 22). These were Jewish translation choices made centuries before Christianity.
Counter-Missionary Argument (Gerald Sigal / Asher Norman)
"Trinity is incompatible with Jewish monotheism"
Response
The Hebrew Bible itself contains plurality within unity (Genesis 1:26 "Let us make," the Angel of YHWH passages, Wisdom personified in Proverbs 8). Second Temple Judaism had robust theological resources for divine plurality including Memra theology, Wisdom theology, and Two Powers theology documented in Alan Segal's scholarship.
Counter-Missionary Argument (Various)
"Paul invented Christianity; the original disciples were Torah-observant Jews"
Response
Paul did not invent Christianity. Acts 15 records the Jerusalem Council settling questions of Gentile inclusion. Paul received and transmitted apostolic tradition (1 Corinthians 15:1-11). The earliest Jewish believers including James, John, and Peter accepted Paul's ministry and message (Galatians 2:9).
Counter-Missionary Argument (Standard counter-missionary teaching)
"Isaiah 53 refers to Israel, not an individual Messiah"
Response
Before Rashi (1040-1105), mainstream Jewish interpretation understood Isaiah 53 as messianic. Targum Jonathan ben Uzziel, the Babylonian Talmud (Sanhedrin 98b), and other early sources apply this passage to the Messiah. The "Israel reading" emerged in medieval Jewish-Christian polemics.
Counter-Missionary Argument (Tovia Singer)
"The "virgin birth" is based on a mistranslation of Isaiah 7:14"
Response
The word almah refers to a young woman of marriageable age, which in the ancient context implied virginity. The Septuagint translators (Jewish scholars before Christianity) chose parthenos (virgin) to translate this word. The sign must be supernatural to be a sign at all.
Counter-Missionary Argument (Various)
"Jesus did not come from the line of David because Joseph was not his biological father"
Response
Jewish succession was commonly traced through adoption (legal paternity). Moreover, Luke's genealogy may trace Mary's line. Ruth was a Moabitess yet is in the Davidic line. The legal principle is well-established in Jewish law.
Counter-Missionary Argument (Outreach Judaism)
"The New Testament contradicts the Torah"
Response
Jesus explicitly stated he came to fulfill the Torah, not abolish it (Matthew 5:17). The apostolic teaching distinguishes between ceremonial law (fulfilled in Christ) and moral law (still binding). This is consistent with prophetic expectation of a new covenant (Jeremiah 31:31-34).
Breaking texts into isolated fragments divorced from their literary and historical context to deny messianic interpretation.
How to Respond
Read passages in their full canonical context. Jesus and the apostles read Scripture holistically, seeing patterns and types throughout.
Claiming only the "original" meaning matters, denying typological or sensus plenior interpretation.
How to Respond
Jewish interpretation itself used pesher, typology, and sensus plenior. The New Testament's interpretive methods were thoroughly Jewish.
Interpreting texts specifically to refute Christian claims rather than seeking the text's meaning.
How to Respond
Compare with pre-Christian Jewish sources (Targums, Dead Sea Scrolls, early Midrash) to see how passages were understood before Christian polemics.
Citing only scholars who support counter-missionary conclusions while ignoring mainstream scholarship.
How to Respond
Engage broadly with the full range of biblical scholarship, including evangelical, mainline, and Jewish academic voices.
Answering Jewish Objections to Jesus (5 volumes)
Comprehensive response to virtually every counter-missionary argument. Brown is a Messianic Jewish scholar with PhD in Near Eastern Languages.
The Messiah in the Old Testament
Scholarly treatment of messianic prophecy demonstrating direct messianic interpretation is legitimate.
The Messianic Hope
Professor at Moody Bible Institute. Demonstrates Jesus fits the prophetic pattern throughout the Hebrew Bible.
Chosen People Ministries resources
Practical ministry resources for engaging Jewish people with the gospel respectfully.
Christians studying the Tanakh and engaging Jewish people should approach with humility, respect, and genuine love. Arguments alone do not convert anyone; the Holy Spirit works through loving witness.
Recognize the Christian church's painful history of supersessionism and antisemitism. Acknowledge failures honestly.
Distinguish between theological disagreement and personal hostility. You can disagree theologically while maintaining respect.
Avoid using the Tanakh as a debate weapon; engage as fellow students of God's word seeking truth together.
Demonstrate genuine love for the Jewish people, recognizing them as the people from whom Messiah came (Romans 9:5).
Pray for Israel and for Jewish friends. Prayer is more powerful than argument.
Live a Christ-centered life that demonstrates the truth of the gospel through transformation.
The goal is not to win arguments but to humbly point Jewish friends toward the Messiah their own Scriptures testify of — and to do so with the love Jesus demonstrated.
Answering Jewish Objections to Jesus (5 volumes)
Michael L. Brown — Baker Books
The definitive response to counter-missionary arguments. Volume 1-2 cover general objections, Volume 3 covers messianic prophecy, Volume 4 covers New Testament objections, Volume 5 covers traditional Jewish objections.
The Messianic Hope
Michael Rydelnik — B&H Academic
Academic defense of direct messianic prophecy interpretation. Responds to minimalist approaches.
Two Powers in Heaven
Alan F. Segal — Brill / Hendrickson
Scholarly demonstration that early Judaism had theological categories for divine plurality. Shows Trinity is not foreign to Jewish thought.